9/7/2016 0 Comments Welcome Cross Creek educators to the Mindsets in the Classroom Book Study! My name is Ali Thetford and we are going to approach professional development in a slightly different manner this year. First, we are using a book study format that has been creeping into our profession recently. Many teachers have commented on the depth of conversation taking place on blogs and have been surprised at their own involvement. In addition to the online element, we will come together at certain times during the study to talk about the ways we are applying the elements behind growth mindset within our classrooms and even our own life. When students believe that dedication and hard work can change their performance in school, they grow to become resilient, successful students. Inspired by the popular mindset idea that hard work and effort can lead to success, Mindsets in the Classroom provides educators with ideas for ways to build a growth mindset school culture, wherein students are challenged to change their thinking about their abilities and potential. The book includes a planning template, step-by-step description of a growth mindset culture, and "look-fors" for adopting a differentiated, responsive instruction model teachers can use immediately in their classrooms. (From the publishers) In this hybrid book study teachers will earn a total of 12 hours (1.2 ceu's) for reading each chapter, responding to discussion prompts online, and sharing application of ideas. You will be given no later than (NLT) dates for completing chapters. I want to thank Melissa Storms for giving me much needed help with this study. In growth mindset fashion, I had to experience a little failure in order to become a better blogger. Pre-assessmentDirections: Click on the button below. Read each statement, rate the level of your proficiency/knowledge/skill and post your results and goals online (see format example): Share your results and goals online:
*Complete the Mindset Implementation Self-Assessment prior to beginning the book. Share your responses below. You are welcome to comment on one other teacher's entry. **Write a learning goal statement for the book study based on your self-assessment results. Share your goal statement below. FORMAT EXAMPLE: Pre-assessment A. Thetford 9/8/2016 * When I read the self-assessment statements I started to think about my actual class practices versus how I think I embed a culture of "growth mindset" in my classroom. While I believe that all students have the potential to improve, not all students are going to take advantage of it. I guess that's part of my struggle as an educator. How many times have I taught obviously "gifted" students who are apathetic, only willing to do the minimum required? On the other hand, how many times have I taught "struggling" students who never gave up and may not be an "A" student, but their efforts have allowed them to move forward. How much more could the "gifted" student achieve if he, too, worked as hard as the "struggling" student? How much more could my students achieve if I promoted the ideas of work, persistence, and failure as stepping stones to improvement? **My goal for this book study is to give the idea behind growth mindset a chance and to deliberately infuse growth mindset practices in my classroom.
36 Comments
9/18/2016 03:17:11 pm
Pre-Assessment:
Reply
9/19/2016 03:16:59 am
Thanks again, Sra. Rappold for your reply. Do you feel a teacher can make or break a student's love of language acquisition (especially in level one?)? Let's continue this conversation throughout the book study. Please forgive this submission if it's a duplicate. I am a novice and wasn't quite sure if the first post posted!
Reply
Kelley Hasapis
9/19/2016 07:14:43 am
After completing the Growth Mindset Implementation Self-Assessment I realized that I am better in some areas than others. When it comes to offering praise and believing my students can achieve at high levels, I am between Practioner and Expert (Questions 1, 3, and 6). I am actually proud of my growth mindset in these areas, and I feel that my strength resides in how I relate to my students; I constantly encourage and offer praise. However, I also realize that I have a ways to go in other areas (Questions 2, 4, and 5). Teaching critical thinking and learning more about how the brain works are areas that I need to concentrate on. I know that by learning more about this and implementing my findings in my lessons will be a key component in student achievement.
Reply
9/20/2016 08:00:19 am
Thank you Ms. Hasapis for your reply. I am glad you constantly encourage and offer praise. As you will soon see, there is an extension to those elements and, as Dr. Dweck says, "It makes all the difference!"
Reply
Julia Little
9/19/2016 06:42:59 pm
Mindset Implementation Self-Assessment
Reply
9/20/2016 07:51:02 am
Thank you for your reply, Dr. Little. As you work through this year you will have many questions on how to best maximize teaching/learning experiences. One example of "everyone must put something in writing" is a simple exit ticket. Even if the group worked on a lab together and perhaps produced one report, you could ask for each student to produce a half sheet summary of the lab (no help from partners) or a 3-2-1 (effective, but don't overuse), just to name two.
Reply
Jennison Shields
9/20/2016 07:30:59 am
After completing the self-assessment, I believe I am a practitioner for 1,3, and 4. I am an apprentice for 5 and 6, and a novice for 2. I actively try to teach critical thinking and the need for perseverance to improve in math. I also know that with effort, all students can improve in math. I am working on praising students for effort more, though I am not a practitioner yet. I'm also not quite sure how the labels fit in with differentiated work. Students quickly realize which groups have the more challenging assignment, and there are students who are always in the group with more challenging work. So though I am not labeling them, they self-label.
Reply
9/20/2016 08:18:57 am
Thank you very much for your reply Ms. Shields. Yes, creating moments for students to think critically (so hard that it hurts) means you instinctively know and subsequently offer opportunities for growth. Reminding all students (struggling and high fliers) that perseverance and persistence can be, at times, uncomfortable but necessary for growth and should be a part of every math teacher's mantra. Food for thought: what do we do when students give up (strugglers) or only willing to go so far (high fliers) in their learning? What is our response?
Reply
Kenny Huffman
9/20/2016 09:24:03 am
I believe I am a practitioner for all the questions except #2. I believe that through artful questioning, students begin to develop their critical thinking skills. Critical thinking can be applied to any aspect of a student's life. If students walk away from my classroom better prepared to make informed decisions, I feel that we've achieved growth. . .
Reply
9/21/2016 06:33:47 am
Hello Mr. Huffman, thank you very much for your response. Many responded as you did in regards to statement number two (conceptual understanding of how the brain works). Mindset research concludes that when students do have a working understanding of the brain in regards to mindset, students will be more open to the ideas therein. Food for thought-perhaps ACR or R-Time is the best place to introduce the ideas of neural plasticity and, as we've done before, when opportunities arise in the classroom to embed a growth mindset moment, we go for it!
Reply
Tiffany Starling
9/20/2016 09:47:00 am
Looking at the self-assessment, I am a practitioner for 1, 3, 4, and 6. I am an apprentice for 2, and a novice for 5. I do believe all students can achieve and be successful, but they must think critically and work hard. Most students either love math or they hate it, so I try to encourage and praise my students on their efforts not just their grades. This seems to promote more enthusiasm for completing the math problems. I could incorporate how the brain works into math a little more. As far as not labeling the students, I need to work on that. I don’t necessarily tell them that they are gifted or smart, but I do let them know their work is more challenging then what they would have at their home school. I believe that everyone is intelligent, but like Albert Einstein once said, “If you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will go its whole life thinking it is stupid”. Every student might not be good in every subject, but it you relate it to what they are good at, then I believe they will be more motivated to learn. My goal is to learn more about how to incorporate growth mindset in the classroom and to incorporate how the brain works into math.
Reply
9/21/2016 06:54:40 am
Thanks so much Ms. Starling for your response. I am afraid to say, but math teachers are at the tip of the spear when it comes to mindset. As high school teachers we get students that have had a lifetime of math experiences and many times it's not the overt declarations of inability (or the opposite), but the subtle messages from previous teachers, parents, friends, and even self-talk.
Reply
Alexis Howard
9/20/2016 07:36:15 pm
After taking the self evaluation of having a growth vs fixed mindset in the classroom, I believe that I am more of a practitioner for numbers 1,3,4,6. I am a firm believer that any student,with enough hard work and perseverance, can excel in the classroom. I am constantly giving them opportunities to get outside of the box when applying the content they are learning. I do know I still have more room for improvement on this area though. As teachers, we should never get to a point to where we have no more room to grow. I regularly try to enforce a positive and safe environment in my classroom, that will encourage kids to not be afraid to ask questions and make mistakes. Sometimes, those moments are the most teachable moments. I do feel, though, I am an apprentice level for numbers 2 & 5. I do my best to break down the content to a level that they should be able to understand, but with the complexities of biology and chemistry, sometimes it is hard to do that.
Reply
9/21/2016 08:04:33 am
Thank you very much for your response, Ms. Howard. You will be excited to know that the upcoming chapters will give you practical advice/instructions on how to maximize students working in the classroom. The most challenging type of student, for me, is the high achieving, but complacent student. They need to know what struggle, persistence, and perseverance looks and feels like.
Reply
Rod Hosking
9/21/2016 04:39:14 am
I would say that I am, for the most part and with varying degrees of success, a level 3 for all but #2. Many of these highlight the need for understanding and implementing rigor and its relationship to student potential.
Reply
9/21/2016 07:48:51 am
You didn't mention your overall goal for the book study. You can comment now or just mention it in the next submission.
Reply
Rod Hosking
9/23/2016 02:10:31 pm
My goal is to consider the merits of teaching students the conceptual understanding of how the brain works as this was the one I felt I was not a practioner in and may find through this book study the value of doing so. 9/22/2016 07:19:01 am
Hi Mr. Hosking,
Reply
9/26/2016 05:06:44 pm
Thank you, Mr. Hosking, for your reply. As Ms. Patrick mentioned in her post (Sousa) perhaps we need to look at the ideas behind brain function and see if we can use that information to help students achieve at a higher capacity.
Jane Merritt
9/21/2016 07:19:17 am
After completing the Mindset Implantation Self-Assessment I believe that I am a practioner for most of the questions. My goal for the book study is to learn more about growth mindset and how to incorporate it more in my classroom.
Reply
9/22/2016 06:58:49 am
Hi Ms. Merritt, Please reply and cite a couple of examples of how you are a practitioner (Don't forget to mention which statements you are referring to in your reply). Is there one statement that you classified yourself as a novice, apprentice, expert? Why?
Reply
K. R. McGinnis
9/21/2016 07:40:19 am
To claim that I am an expert in anything is, frankly, disingenuous. I would be remiss, however, to not mention that, of all of the areas, I feel the most like an expert in number 1, the belief that all students can achieve and be successful.
Reply
9/22/2016 06:29:01 am
Thank you Mr. McGinnis for your thoughtful response. I am glad you mentioned your fundamental belief that all students can achieve. I think it is most frustrating (and perhaps our faith can be tested) when students seem to sabotage their own learning. There are plenty of examples of young people who quit school, only to come back, get their GED, go to college, and achieve a degree. So, what's the deal? Is it wisdom? Is it circumstances? It is financial? Combination of all these factors? Perhaps it is a realization that there must be work, struggle, and even failure to get something prized.
Reply
P Patrick
9/21/2016 10:27:01 am
After the self assessment I need to pull out Sousa's book on How the Brain Works. I have not used Sousa's materials in some time.
Reply
P. Patrick
9/22/2016 07:10:06 am
I need to add to my post. That I am a Practioner in 3, 4, and 5. By no means am I an expert but questions #1 and #6 are questions based my beliefs and how I am commanded to treat others.
Reply
9/22/2016 07:32:19 am
Thanks Ms. Patrick for your post. Yes, I saw the same thread about brain research as you. I also looked at Sousa's work and I think you are on the right track. As I posted, Dr. Dweck's research suggests that even if students are just made *aware* of this thing called growth mindset they are more accepting of the concept. For CC educators, an overview of brain research/meta-cognition may be worth exploring. Neural plasticity is the hub to the spokes of growth mindset.
Gina Hickle
9/21/2016 01:08:42 pm
In applying the components of the self-assessment to counseling, I feel comfortable saying I rate myself as a practitioner (a "3" ) in all the mentioned areas. In counseling students, it is essential for them to know that you believe in their potential or a positive rapport will not develop. It is equally important for a counselor to gently prompt students into thinking critically about their actions, their beliefs, and their habits and the inevitable effect these have on their mental health and overall general well-being. Counselors are charged with the responsibility of helping others think through the choices they make and the resulting potential consequences they may or may not be equipped to handle. Essential to this endeavor is helping students realize they are capable of making sound decisions and part of that includes taking ownership of the outcome. My goal will be to make a conscious effort to implement the concepts of growth mindset into a counseling framework in my work with students in both individual and group counseling settings.
Reply
9/22/2016 07:06:01 am
Hello Ms. Hickle,
Reply
Tashiana Reynolds
9/21/2016 04:31:25 pm
After reading through the assessment, I found myself to be a practitioner of most goals. I hope to learn more about how the brain works and how to frame lessons that challenge my students to think critically.
Reply
9/22/2016 06:56:14 am
Hi Ms. Reynolds. Please reply and cite a couple of examples of how you are a practitioner (Don't forget to mention which statements you are referring to in your reply). Is there one statement that you classified yourself as a novice or apprentice? Why?
Reply
Tashiana Reynolds
9/22/2016 08:29:01 am
I think that I am a practitioner of statements 1, 3, 5, and 6. For example, I think that every student I teach has the ability to be successful not only in my class, but in their other classes as well. There would never be a time in which would look at a student and think to myself "they aren't capable of success". I think part of our duty as educators is to help students realize their capabilities. Also, I do realize the negative effects of labeling students as "gifted". These students are often not challenged enough and when they do meet academic challenges, such as college level work, they are not prepared to handle the workload.
Reply
9/26/2016 04:48:26 pm
Hi Ms. Reynolds, thanks for adding a bit more information. There is much to learn the first few years of teaching and I think you have already experienced a few set-backs when your students do not respond as you "had hoped for." In an ironic twist you can use the ideas behind growth mindset for your own professional development. Instead of "giving up" on engaging strategies, try different ones or be willing to change certain aspects in order to get desired results. After getting to know you last week, I am positive that will be your course of action. We really can grow in the face of failure if we are willing to take the chance in the first place.
Reply
Keno Kerr
9/22/2016 09:19:43 am
Since completing the Assessment I have come to the realization that I am a novice in the area of teaching student a conceptual conceptual understanding of how the brain works ( number 2 ). I will put this into practice now that it has become apparent to me.
Reply
9/26/2016 05:02:36 pm
Good evening, Mr. Kerr, Thank you very much for your post. Throughout the entire blog postings, number two, conceptual understanding of the brain, seems to be the one statement that most on the faculty have in common for *needing improvement.* As I mentioned earlier, Dr. Dweck's research suggests that even if students are just made *aware* of this thing called growth mindset they are more accepting of the concept (and act upon the knowledge).
Reply
9/22/2016 09:11:17 pm
Mindsets-- Self assessment
Reply
9/26/2016 05:13:22 pm
Thanks Ms. Rivera for your reply. In the next few weeks you will soon see that this idea behind growth mindset goes well beyond signals of encouragement and praise. There is a place for those things, to be sure, but you will also find that we need to get students to think in a growth frame of mind even without the teacher present! Also, as I have said in numerous other posts, stay tuned for more information in regards to creating an enhanced growth mindset in your class and ultimately, in the school.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Archives |